Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
MigBuster

Sea Harrier FRS 1 vs Mirage III & Dagger

Recommended Posts

Cover.JPG.70b2f8a29a414c55d518144d14bf5fe6.JPG

 

This is one of the latest and recently released books in Osprey Publishing’s “Duel” series focusing primarily on two of the major aircraft types in the South Atlantic conflict of 1982.

There is already quite a lot of very good information written by the people who were there on this subject, however what I really like about the Osprey series is they are short & very concise and this book brings a lot of previous information together in one place, as well as telling us a few new things.

 

The two main authors are:

Doug Dildy – A retired USAF colonel and former F-15 pilot who worked with SHARs operationally and in air-to-air training during his first NATO tour of duty. Dildy lives in Albuquerque, NM.

Pablo Calcaterra - A Canadian citizen from Argentina. He is an avid and award winning aircraft modeller, with direct access to the Argentine Air Force archives and contact with many veterans of the conflict. Calcaterra lives in London, Ontario.

Other notable contributions to the book include from the Argentine FAA:

Brigadier Mayor Guillermo Donadille, Brigadiers Gustavo Piuma Justo, Carlos Perona, and Comodoros Raúl Díaz, Jorge Senn and Luis Puga.

 

And from the British FAA SHAR Pilots:

Cdr Nigel ‘Sharkey’ Ward, Lt Cdrs Mike ‘Soapy’ Watson and David Smith. 

 

The book covers in more detail:

·         The design and development of the Sea Harrier, Mirage IIIEA and the Dagger (Mirage V);

·         The exact weapons that were used by both in the conflict;

·         Looks at pilot training and some tactics from both sides;

·         A look at the overall Strategic situation of the conflict.

 

The main section “Combat” looks at the engagements from both points of view but also includes the other aircraft and ships involved giving a good overview of the conflict. Lastly statistics and analysis of the conflict are looked at with some of the major points highlighted.

 

We get a fairly balanced book from many view points, which is essential because looking at something from only a single point of view can never show us the big picture.

Overall one of my favourites so far and recommended to anyone who wants a good overview of the sometimes-ferocious air war in the South Atlantic, because make no mistake, despite the short period the loss of life was sometimes horrific and I hope this only sheds more light on their bravery and sacrifice.

 

 

 

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the review, had this on my sights for a while, it seems is good enough to buy it. Always wondered how a A-A radar equipped A-4 would have performed there...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, now it's on the eventual purchase list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Stratos


      View File DH Osprey B.II
      De Havilland Osprey B.II by Cocas (what if...) 28/07/2017
       
      Some time ago I requested some updates to the original Osprey by Cocas, a refuelling probe, airbrakes, antenna on the fuselage... cocas made the mod and I made a new skin for strategical use with the RAF in AntiFlash white. As the Osprey B.II does not differ wildly from the I, I retained the original readme and completed with some historical background. As the plane was never used on the desert being based only in UK and Germany, I not included the desert scheme, but the one in the original Osprey will work. For the Malvinas campaign, the green euro cammo should be used.
       
      Model by cocas, new antiflash white skin by Stratos on cocas template, decals by Spinners. Thanks a lot guys!
       
      Background:
       
      Following the exit of the first version of the new De Havilland bird, the RAF aproached De Havilland with a request for a improved variant with Strategic bombing as its designed mission. The requirements were clear, a better range, a refuelling probe and a long range communication radio.
       
      De Havilland felt it was pretty easy to complete the task, as the requested features were already imagined for the Osprey, and added another one, big air brakes on the wings. the refuelling probe was a bit more complicated, as it was tested first on the starboard wing, but it was hard to use in flying, specially in bad weather conditions, so a reuleing probe over the cockpit was installed and tested. It came with the risk of spilling gas on the cockpit glass, but simplified the refueling maneuvers a lot, so it was finally selected as the choosen one. The new communication array was based on a dorsal antenna and new radio equipment to be controlled by the copilot, as the plane retained the three man crew.
       
      Finally bigger fuel tanks were installed and the new brakes air tested, those brakes improved maneuvers and shortened the landing run quite a bit, and then the prototype was sent to the RAF for testing. Plane was well liked by its crews and the RAf operated 49 of the birs in the nuclear bomber role, both based on UK and in RAf stations in Germany. During the first years the Osprey B.II used the classic Anti Flash white scheme, before converting to a regular cammo scheme as it was seen in the Malvinas campaign before retirement.
       
      On the following pics, we can see a recently delivered Osprey B.II in anti flash white belonging to the squadron flying low over the Mach Loop in Wales, training for low level nuclear attack runs on Warsaw Pact targets.
      Submitter Stratos Submitted 07/28/2017 Category What If Hangar  
    • By denissoliveira


      View File IAI PACK Argentine Air Force
      IAI FINGER A Argentine Air Force (2.0)
       
      Install - Need Update July 2012 and DLC Mirage IIIO
       
      IAI Finger is a jet fighter and bomber Mach 2.2 used by the Air Force Argentina .
      Finger is the name of a modernization program carried out at the
      planes made ??in Israel IAI Dagger possessed the Argentina Republic .
       
      Modelo - TK (Mirage IIIO)
      Texture - Denis Oliveira
      Template Texture - Ludo.m54
      3D mod - Denis Oliveira
      Decals - Denis Oliveira
      Modified TW Nesher Cockpit tiles and Avioncs ini - Coupi
       
      Dagger B
       
      The remaining Israeli Nesher aircrafts were refurbished and exported to the Argentine Air Force in two batches, 26 in 1978 and 13 in 1980, under the name Dagger, comprising 35 Dagger A single-seat fighters and 4 Dagger B two-seat trainers.
       
      They formed a new unit, 6th Air Group, and were immediately enlisted with the help of the 8th Air Group (Mirage IIIEA) and the Peruvian Air Force, already a user of the Mirage 5, due to the escalating crisis with Chile of that year.
       
      During the 1982 Falklands War, they were deployed to the southern naval airbase of Río Grande, Tierra del Fuego, and an airfield in Puerto San Julián and despite the distance to their targets and lack of aerial refueling capability, managed to make 153 sorties against both ground and naval targets on the 45 days of operations. In the last role, they damaged HMS Antrim, Brilliant, Broadsword, Ardent, Arrow and Plymouth. Eleven Daggers were lost in combat (nine by AIM-9L Sidewinders fired from Sea Harriers and two by surface to air missiles).
       
      In the 1979 contract with IAI, the Argentine Air Force stipulated that the Daggers would be equipped with new avionics and HUD systems to take them to the Kfir C.2 (and beyond in some subsystems) standard. The program, named Finger, was underway in 1982 when the Falklands War broke out. With the war over, as some of these systems were made by the British Marconi Electronic Systems, they needed to be replaced after an arms embargo was imposed by the UK. The replacement of such systems took the planes to the final Finger IIIB standard mainly by replacing the British equipment with French-built Thomson-CSF.
       
      Texture Temp by Ludo.m54
      Texture: PauloPanz
      Decals: PauloPanz
      Data.ini: Coupi
      3D mod: Denis Oliveira
      Submitter denissoliveira Submitted 07/09/2016 Category Israeli Origin  
    • By dtmdragon


      View File Sea Harrier FRS.2 AMRAAM station update/ correction
      Sea Harrier FRS.2 Aim-120 AMRAAM fuselage station update/ correction.
       
      This is an update to the Sea Harrier FRS.2 for SF2 V1.1 that replaces and corrects the fuselage Aim-120 weapon pylons and positioning.
       
      Simply place in your mods folder and OVERRIDE when prompted.
       
      Notes:
       
      The pylon is set up as a weapons station the same before but it is used 4 times instead of 2 to get the right length.
       
      You must have the Sea Harrier FRS.2 for SF2 V1.1
       
      http://combatace.com/files/file/12956-sea-harrier-frs2/
       
       
       
      Credits for the SF2 Shar FA.2:
       
      Russouk2004
       
      USAFMTL
       
      DTMDragon
       
      Wrench - also for the 'new' weapons pylon.
       
      ChrisBV
       
      AmokFloo
       
      AleDucat
       
      Monty CZ
       
      Kesselbrut
       
      VolksJager.
       
      Ravenclaw007
       
      IanH
      Submitter dtmdragon Submitted 02/21/2016 Category Harrier  
    • By dtmdragon


      View File BAE Sea Harrier II FA.5 (what if)
      SF2 BAE Sea Harrier II FA.5 (what if)
       
       
       
      What if instead of upgrading their Sea Harrier FRS.1 to the FA.2 standard the Royal Navy joined the Harrier II program that produced the Harrier GR.5/7/9?
       
      And so I give you the Sea Harrier FA.5/7/9
       
       
       
      Credits:
       
      -Bobrock
       
      -Brian32
       
      -Dave
       
      -Wrench
       
      -ianh755
       
      -ravenclaw_007
       
       
       
       
       
      Instillation:
       
      Drop into your mods folder and override when prompted.
       
      Note:
       
      Has only been tested in a merged install of all SF2 titles.
       
       
       
      Enjoy,
       
      Dan (dtmdragon)
      Submitter dtmdragon Submitted 02/21/2016 Category What If Hangar  
    • By denissoliveira


      View File IAI Dagger B
      Dagger B
       
      The remaining Israeli Nesher aircrafts were refurbished and exported to the Argentine Air Force in two batches, 26 in 1978 and 13 in 1980, under the name Dagger, comprising 35 Dagger A single-seat fighters and 4 Dagger B two-seat trainers.
       
      They formed a new unit, 6th Air Group, and were immediately enlisted with the help of the 8th Air Group (Mirage IIIEA) and the Peruvian Air Force, already a user of the Mirage 5, due to the escalating crisis with Chile of that year.
       
      During the 1982 Falklands War, they were deployed to the southern naval airbase of Río Grande, Tierra del Fuego, and an airfield in Puerto San Julián and despite the distance to their targets and lack of aerial refueling capability, managed to make 153 sorties against both ground and naval targets on the 45 days of operations. In the last role, they damaged HMS Antrim, Brilliant, Broadsword, Ardent, Arrow and Plymouth. Eleven Daggers were lost in combat (nine by AIM-9L Sidewinders fired from Sea Harriers and two by surface to air missiles).
       
      In the 1979 contract with IAI, the Argentine Air Force stipulated that the Daggers would be equipped with new avionics and HUD systems to take them to the Kfir C.2 (and beyond in some subsystems) standard. The program, named Finger, was underway in 1982 when the Falklands War broke out. With the war over, as some of these systems were made by the British Marconi Electronic Systems, they needed to be replaced after an arms embargo was imposed by the UK. The replacement of such systems took the planes to the final Finger IIIB standard mainly by replacing the British equipment with French-built Thomson-CSF.
       
      Texture Temp by Ludo.m54
      Texture: PauloPanz
      Decals: PauloPanz
      Data.ini: Coupi
      3D mod: Denis Oliveira
      Submitter denissoliveira Submitted 05/18/2015 Category Israeli Origin  
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.