hi peter01,
no not naive....not at all (seriously).
Personaly I'm still stucked with my Thrustmaster TopGun Afterburner II (and CHPro Pedals). I know it does not have all the bells & whistles of a X52, but it's rugged and does it's job. .....AND has FFB! At the beginning I tought it's just a gimmick, but after a while, with a bit of 'tuning' it's rather fun feeling the rumble/shaking when you press the trigger for the MG or even more shaking when you press the other button for the guns (like in a BF109 in IL2).
Concerning the flying feeling......like stalls, etc. well my experience is rather mixed....it basically depends on the used game (IL2, FSX, FS9, FE, BOBII, BOB, etc.) a couple of them are doing it better than others....
rgds
gt