There's a good topic I found last night (Vampyre can probably tell you) on the Fighter Ops forums that Sundowner from Poland outlines some deficiencies (thrust to weight, speed of course critical) of the SH. I agree to the point that if it had a better speed and longer ranged armament, it could do the job as effective as the Tomcat. But that's pretty much what the SH is good for, bombing the bejeezus (okay, if the detractors are right, reach it) out of somebody, as it's got the space and pylons for it. Given the report from Carlo Kopp it sheds some more light on the subject. And a topic I read on the VNFA website pretty much said that the Navy needed something New NOW. The Tomcat will always be a fond memory, but when you're looking at basically spending alot of money to revamp a 1970s era aircraft to which parts are becoming scarce (factories aren't even producing the parts, at least some of them, and more than likely won't retool, and to update the fire control suite, you had to literally rewire it, and there wasn't any emphasis for that. They got enough money to at least get the LANTIRN pods for it, which I'm sure alot of grunts downrange are glad for), and you have to use scrap from AMARC, which adds to the bill. Instead you got the bean counters saying "Hey this plane, it's not as great as the Tomcat, it saves money and furthermore, it's rolling off the assembly line, and we don't have to search the whole planet for spares." Plus pilots like the reliability, so that's more planes in the air, and etc. etc. About the only mission I would say in somewhat defense of the SH, is that Tomcat never could to airborne refuelling, or at least perform the tanker role which was of course lost when the KA-6D was retired too. Could they have modified Tomcats? Of course, but that didn't happen. Sure the SH needs more fuel, but nobody (not even the Navy bean counters) wanted to improve the Tomcat either, as it itself was a victim of politics. I mean we can always like or hate the SH, and forever love the Tomcat, but whatever we think, the US Navy made it's decision, right or wrong, and we just have to live with their decision.