Best Naval Combat \ Submarine Sims

[RUSTYMORLEY 162]

Okay I just had to follow on from my post about the Best First Person Shooters. So here we go. What are your best Naval Combat or Submarine sims for the PC. Personally speaking I have enjoyed Battlestations Pacific, Silent Hunter 3 and Silent Hunter 4 including the add-on games, and even though they are quite old now I still take them out for a spin on a regular basis. You know the drill, feel free to list your Top Ten games. Fire away!!!!

[+JonathanRL 974]

Naval War: Arctic Circle is well worth playing.

[Do335 382]

had a search for naval games recently. slim pickings tbh given that i wasn't too much into subs and a big no to arcade stuff. there was a review of Jutland on simhq a few years ago, so took a look into that, but apparently the game has gone fubar. so per some other reco ended up with Steam and Iron. Run the campaign, manage yer fleet, sink the enemy battleships, everything can be modded... aside from the 2D graphics it was really great.

[Piglet_7 106]

Sub Command and Dangerous Waters, the voice commands gives it tension so think it will leave you fighting for air.

[macelena 1,070]

http://www.amazon.com/Discovery-Channel-Multimedia-Pirates-Captains/dp/B000KRRBEG/ref=sr_1_2?s=videogames&ie=UTF8&qid=1412033696&sr=1-2

 

 

I dare you all to find some funnier than this one. I loved it.

[Skyviper 1,101]

Monkey Island? That was funny.

 

 

But to answer the question. Silent Hunter ... by default for me because that is only Navl Sim game I've ever played. What I would really really really really really really really like to play is a game like Battlestations Midway but for the modern navy. People think it would be too easy to just hit a button and launch a missile. But I think there are more tactics involved. Not to mention the deployment of Marines and Navy Seals and subs doing covert ops ... hell or just doing covert ops.

 

But yeah Silent Hunter Wolves of the Paciific for me. I'ld love to more sims that would allow one to be hands on.

[+logan4 847]

The only naval/underwater sim I ever played was AquaNox1-2, not sure if that classifies by your terms. I did like it although my rig that time was a bit weak for its requirements.

[Snailman 517]

Submarine:   Dangerous Waters   (would be a dream to connect with SF series to conduct ASW)

Modern warship:   Dangerous waters, although it focuses on ASW

                              Harpoon series (and it's derivatives like Arctic circle)

WW2:    Aces of the deep (maybe Silent hunter series is better, but I played more with that, that time)

              Great Naval battles series (old, I know but haven't seen such ever since)

              Battlestations series, well not a sim, but the graphics are near perfect... so I have to mention this one too. I could use a read sim/strategy with the same gfx engine!

 

Im really sorry about Dangerous water being not so modder friendly, I could use that system to make it a decent Harpoon substitute... 

[macelena 1,070]

Anyone ever played Fast Attack? It had a cool interface, yet didn´t allow you to peek out like you would do in silent hunter. It was more immersive in some areas, like not being able to use an external view, and using cut scenes and so on, didn´t require much power to look nice. I remember even the mission i was playing on the PC when i heard my parents, startled by an aircraft crash in New York call me just in time to watch live how the second plane hit WTC

 

 

[+allenjb42 4,234]

I loved Janes Fleet Command and will always have a soft spot for the old Red Storm Rising sub sim game.
 

Edited September 30, 2014 by allenjb42

[B52STRATO 215]

- Silent Hunter III + GWX 3.0, playable surface units & S-Boote mods

- Dangerous Waters + Red Alert mod 1.37

- Naval War : Artic Circle  (Pretty realistic, here you can test that the Kirov-class CGNs represents one true AA and anti-ship menace, but lacks ASW capabilities).

- Silent Hunter IV (well patched, of course)

 

Silent Hunter V is apart and forms a good bug 'n' lag FPS.

[+Gepard 11,314]

Harpoon

Burning Steel

Silent Hunter

[Stratos 3,192]

The best naval simulator ever, no doubt.

 

http://www.matrixgames.com/products/483/details/Command:.Modern.Air.Naval.Operations

[KJakker 901]

Fighting Steel is one of my favorites.

 

http://www.subsim.com/ssr/fightst2.html

 

The Fighting Steel Project upgrade.

 

http://nws-online.proboards.com/thread/17/fighting-steel-project

 

Also "WARSHIP COMBAT - NAVIES AT WAR" for a 2D turn based simulation.

 

http://nws-online.proboards.com/thread/4/warship-combat-navies-information-downloads

[RUSTYMORLEY 162]

One of two titles here I have never heard of. Thanks for you replies members !!

[JediMaster 451]

I started with Harpoon and Harpoon 2. Then I played Aces of the Deep, Seawolf, Carriers at War (ok, not really a sim), a little SH3, and LOTS of Dangerous Waters. I spent a lot of time with the OHP for some reason, not too much with the 60 or P-3, and a bit with the subs.

[Do335 382]

captured a video of Steam and Iron game play.

 

keyword for this game... Jutland. and everything else around that event!

[Lt. James Cater 62]

Going way back i played quite a lot of Silent Service I and II. In more recent years Silent Hunter was what i was into.

[Do335 382]

Another epic battle with voice over!

[+Julhelm 266]

Fast Attack and Red Storm Rising are the best modern submarine sims. If you have a phone or tablet and fancy some WW2 Pacific combat, there is always Pacific Fleet.