I generally agree, but are we seriously talking about uploading dozens of thousands of files elsewhere? I'd like to see a discussion about how to make CombatACE more sustainable for Erik given the exorbitant server costs, because if this site dies, all of the files and informations hosted in here will disappear overnight.
Sure, I can upload some of my own mods elsewhere, but I don't own the work of others nor have all TBs of content from this website. To see a community of end-users scattered for downloading mods is not a problem I'm worried about (I frankly don't care, most users are only worried about getting stuff without even caring of posting a thank you note or a review), but to see modders lose a place to reunite and discuss with hundreds of useful topics and threads, that is a problem I care more about.
I agreed about @Erik adding a subscription paywall to downloads for the website because it was either that or the site would have gone 404 the day after. I'm afraid the site's servers are plagued with performance issues, so I feel like this hard decision only bought CA some time before it eventually dies. Let's discuss about how to save this place from dying, preserving all of its history and content, and how we can feasibly make things more accessible for all users, so that we get closer to a win-win situation instead of a lose all situation.