Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Was released in some US theaters last night, "officially" came out today.

 

Who is seeing it?

 

If I weren't half sleep from working a long shift I would be in line right now.

 

fury_ver2_xlg.jpg

Edited by ironroad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes - its out on the 22nd here - the trailers been out a while - so will see it over the next few weeks - should be good.

 

Strangely will be the second War film (kinda) in a few weeks at the flicks - saw 71 - set in 1971 Belfast - this week (v good also)

 

71_2815828b.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Crazyhorse freaked out when i showed the early trailer before summer, so you can count on him. I´m not so sure i´ll  be able to, but sure i wish i could

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not too bad a movie, esp when one turns the mind off and remembers its just a movie.

Read somewhere the last working Tiger tank is featured in the film. The planes and tracers are CGI'd in, but the tanks were certainly real

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brad Pitt was interviewed at the French TV this evening. Sure I'll go and watch, and possibly appreciate it, if it is a good small-crew story, "Memphis Belle" style. I just hope they won't overdo the usual Hollywood paper heroism. For example, the band of heroes here has to face Tiger tanks, of course no less, not the less impressive yet sturdy and dangerous SPGs that were most commonly met by that stage of the War...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah CB34 gave me a run down on it and he gave it a resounding 2 thumbs up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just saw it this evening.  It was as intense and graphic as any flick that I've seen to date, so one may want to think twice before taking young children to see it.  The body count at the end was typical Hollywood, but all in all, I found it an entertaining experience.

 

BTW,  I went to an AMC theatre that featured electric recliners, ala Lazy-Boy, with so much room between rows that one could easily squeeze by even with the foot-rests of the adjacent seats full extended.  It was a treat.

 

amc-recliners.jpg

 

My favorite scene:

 

Edited by Fubar512
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just watched it this morning: good mark. I find that Germany turned mad, ruled by Götterdämmerung fanatics, bogged into the April mud, is a much better stage than Normandy in Summer seen in "Saving Private Ryan". The soundtrack works fine too, supporting the apocalyptic ambiance. Good scene with the stream of heavy bombers passing high, letting countless white trails behind: a true Twilight of the Gods.

 

The asymmetrical crew of odd characters spending their time bawling out each other, a delight for any psychanalyst, is typical Hollywood, but would be a whole crew of burnt losers in real action. We find the usual raw stereotypes with the Bible-licker, the unreedemable toerag (how could such an ugly tall ape be assigned into a small tank!?), the ethnic minority, the ingenuous boy-scout... Brad Pitt is some repetition of Tom Hanks in "Saving Private Ryan": a well-educated man, yet a living god and war emblem for his gang of beasts, breathing war yet still having some heart.

 

During the first part of the movie, I found quite realistic the obstacles met by the advancing Yanks: harassment by mines and small AT teams waiting in cover, AT guns at the edge of the woods, MG nests in the towns, sporadic fire from enemy arty... It reminded me of encounters experienced in my favorite solitary boardgame, "Patton's Best" (Avalon Hill 1987), a jewel. This running part of the movie got me in the mood for letting the game out of the locker. Things get somewhat odd from the clash with the lone Tiger (Fubar's scene above). Why would this tank wait next to some small grove in the middle of large open fields, hidden from the road but spottable by any of the ubiquitous Allied Jabo? And why would the Yanks, having reached pistol range, dance a dangerous tango around the Tiger rather than just ramming it straight on, to neutralize the advantage of its terrible 88 and put the chances on an even sharing in close combat? Some other Allied crews did it in real history

 

And things get completely wrong with the final battle of Alamo. Typical Hollywood: 5 Yank heroes locked into a disabled coffin, versus 200 SS at close range with Panzerfausts? No sweat, will be back by lunch. The tactics (or rather lack of any tactics) displayed there by the Krauts are irrealistically dumb and expensive, with cannon fodder keeping on running stupidly around the immobile tank, while their marching column had been seen previously with Panzerfausts ready to use at shoulder, about one for 10-12 men. The crew should have survived for the duration of a cigarette butt (for besides, they did not even think to empty the tank fuel before the pitched battle). Fubar is right, the last vertical pic giving some idea of the body count around the disabled tank is telling, but really, I don't buy the Alamo thing. Yet, I can't but recommend "Fury" as a movie to be seen by all addicts of rolling armor.

Edited by Capitaine Vengeur

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its astonishing how similar are american and soviet WW2 movies. All american/soviet soldiers are great heros, smart, brave invincible. The Krauts/Fritzuji are dumb cowards.

"Fury" has some good points. The effects are nice, but seen from tactical and technical poit of view it is ridiculus. Its like George Lucas "Red Tails" nonsense.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its astonishing how similar are american and soviet WW2 movies. All american/soviet soldiers are great heros, smart, brave invincible. The Krauts/Fritzuji are dumb cowards.

"Fury" has some good points. The effects are nice, but seen from tactical and technical poit of view it is ridiculus. Its like George Lucas "Red Tails" nonsense.

 

 

I like to know where you find it tactical and technical standpoint when they had this....

 

http://gizmodo.com/how-the-cast-of-fury-trained-for-the-most-realistic-wwi-1647708935

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One Sherman vs hundrets of german soldiers which are armed with Panzerfaust and the Sherman survived. LOL. This tank was known as "Tommy-Kocher" or "Ami-Kocher". One shot with Panzerfaust and the tankcrew will sit on the cloud and sing with the angles.

post-3395-0-29131500-1414874863.jpg

This picture shows a Sherman after hit by Panzerfaust. Its cooked, thatswhy "Ami-Kocher". And this would have been the end of the movie from tactical and technical standpoint. But this would not have been heroic enough for Hollywood.

Edited by Gepard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well then you can say the scenario was bogus. Not from tactical and technical standpoint then. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have learned to knock out tanks from close distance from the scratch. Panzernahbekämpfung was the german term. Believe me, the movieend is LOL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some military expert I read on French website share Gepard's opinion : the whole alamo thing is stupid. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well what would the French know about tank warfare? They were too busy surrendering during WWII!  J/K :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gepard, the "Tommy-Cooker" reputation of very inflammable tanks actually concerned the first versions of the Sherman. The later models like "Fury" enjoyed a "wet stowage" for ammo, storing them with more security. The game I talked about above, "Patton's Best", gives lots of tables and designer's notes to explain that. The M4, M4A1, M4A2 & M4A3 with 75mm gun do not have this option, the "Jumbo" (over-armored) models and all of models with the 76mm gun are equipped with it. In the game, a Sherman without this equipment has 75-80% chance to catch fire if hit and penetrated, only 15-20% if having "wet stowage".

 

And well, Dave, the French in WW2 scored some nice feats regarding tanks. I was talking above of historical occasions when Allied tanks facing heavy Panzers at very close range preferred to ram them straight on, rather than oddly draw esoteric circles around them hoping to have the German crew vomit. I thought especially of one occasion during the Liberation of Paris, when a French Sherman from 2e D.B. faced a big Panther across the famous Place de La Concorde. The Panther had been disabled and deceived by the French M10 "Sirocco", and Sgt Marcel Bizien's Sherman "Douaumont" rushing onto its flank could place a hit on its relatively thin turret side. But it happened to be a smoke shell! No time to reload and the Panther's turret was turning to face the new threat. So Bizien ordered to accelerate and ram the Panzer, yelling "On board!". After the clash, the German crew took advantage of the smoke to evacuate and run away. Commanding from an open cupola, Bizien was killed the moment after by a German sniper. The whole scene can be seen in the movie "Is Paris burning?" where Sgt Bizien was played by Yves Montand.

 

The main mobile group from 2e D.B. involved in the Liberation of Paris was commanded by Colonel Pierre Billotte, who had himself signed some years before another nice armored feat comparable to SS Tiger commander Michael Wittmann's famous death ride at Villers-Bocage in 1944. In may 1940, Billotte was a lieutenant and tank commander (and incidentally, he was also the son of the general commanding the French 1st Army Group, whose fate was to be trapped in the Dunkirk Pocket). During the hard-fought battle of Stonne, Ardennes (South of Sedan), Lt Billotte ventured his lone B1bis tank "Eure" into the hamlet that had just been taken back one more time by the Germans. Regarding gunnery and armor, the B1bis was in 1940 the same terror the Tiger was in 1944. Before falling back out of ammo, Lt Billotte had single-handedly scored 11 Pz.III, 2 Pz.IV, and 2 PaK36 AT guns. His tank was fleckered with over 130 hits between 37 to 75mm, none of them decisive.

Edited by Capitaine Vengeur

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing that no one here mentioned so far, is that they used an actual Tiger 1 in the film, not some silly stand-in, like dressed-up M-48s ( as they did in Patton) or a tarted-up T34 (Kelly's Heros).

 

A much more realistic ending (given the date), would have been for the crew to have encountered an entire platoon of Tigers as they sat disabled at the crossroads.   As this seemingly overwhelming force drew within range,  the crew of the Fury prepared for what was undoubtedly going to be their last battle.  Then they notice that the turrets of their opponents were reversed. The war had ended, thus sparing all.

Edited by Fubar512

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 In may 1940, Billotte was a lieutenant and tank commander (and incidentally, he was also the son of the general commanding the French 1st Army Group, whose fate was to be trapped in the Dunkirk Pocket). During the hard-fought battle of Stonne, Ardennes (South of Sedan), Lt Billotte ventured his lone B1bis tank "Eure" into the hamlet that had just been taken back one more time by the Germans. Regarding gunnery and armor, the B1bis was in 1940 the same terror the Tiger was in 1944. Before falling back out of ammo, Lt Billotte had single-handedly scored 11 Pz.III, 2 Pz.IV, and 2 PaK36 AT guns. His tank was fleckered with over 130 hits between 37 to 75mm, none of them decisive.

Too busy surrendering, indeed.

 

Billote senior was also KIA. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Too busy surrendering, indeed.

 

It was a joke.....its not a dick, don't take it so hard. :lol: 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have learned to knock out tanks from close distance from the scratch. Panzernahbekämpfung was the german term. Believe me, the movieend is LOL.

By the way Gepard, what was the field of equipment and training for that matter in the DDR Army? Portable launchers? Magnetic mines or sticky bombs? Mining and camouflaged ambushes on mandatory ways of advance or retreat? Camouflaged ditch traps? Use of unstable rubble in urban combat? Yet several of these means can work only against moving tanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

By the way Gepard, what was the field of equipment and training for that matter in the DDR Army? Portable launchers? Magnetic mines or sticky bombs? Mining and camouflaged ambushes on mandatory ways of advance or retreat? Camouflaged ditch traps? Use of unstable rubble in urban combat? Yet several of these means can work only against moving tanks.

 

This will become a little bit OT and has few to do with the movie "Fury".

But okay. There was a lot of training i had, starting with molotow cocktail, anti tank handgranade, RPG-7 (only a short introduction), RPG-18 (a lot of time), anti tank mines, making of geballte Ladung (dont know the english term), detecting weak and strong points of panzers, creep into the "dead zones" of a panzer and so on and so on and so on. What a waste of time.

I made some mobilephonephotos of my old military handbook which covers a little bit basic knowledge of Panzernahbekämpfung.

 

post-3395-0-48123600-1414954098.jpg

post-3395-0-22852800-1414954111.jpg

post-3395-0-56848200-1414954133.jpg

post-3395-0-42823500-1414954146.jpg

post-3395-0-68092900-1414954157.jpg

post-3395-0-62825800-1414954170.jpg

post-3395-0-81843400-1414954182.jpg

 

The more important handbook "Panzernahbekämpfung moderner Panzer und Schützenpanzer der NATO" i have at home too. But i will not release pages here, because I dont know, who will read it and i dont want to give the know how to kill an Abrams in wrong hands.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Molotov's? Really? I would've thought that far too ineffective in a modern (ie post-Korea) conflct.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One molotov cocktail is to less, because modern tanks have Freon anti fire systems. But this systems can be activated only 2 or 3 times.

Translated text from the handbook:

"With a molotov cocktail a tank of the opponent cant be annihilated, but harmed efficiently. A well placed molotov cocktail makes a tank unable to move and under certain circumstances it forced the crew to bail out. ..." Then follows the description how to made a molotov cocktail.

 

Personally i liked the "geballte Ladung" much more, because we could play with some kilograms of Semtex (czech plastic explosive relativly similar to C4). I remember that one trainer made a do it yourself shaped charge explosive device which punched easily a hole trough a T-54 turret front. Was a nice big bang. Mixing of Thermit and later igniting was fun too. Cool fireworks.

Only Napalm i disliked, it stinks pathetic.

Edited by Gepard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It was a joke.....its not a dick, don't take it so hard. :lol:

With french as cowards in 2003 during the Iraqi invasion in all forums, we are a litlle sensitive about this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Lacsap


      View File New skins WW2 ETO in 4K for F-51D/K from FastCargo
      YOU MUST HAVE THE F-51D/K from FastCargo !
      -Textures in 4K with Normal map and specular map
      - 3 Fighters Squadron WW2 ETO with invasion strips : 487thFS (x11 nose arts), 343rdFS (x5 nose arts), 375thFS (one nose art! if you know of any websites where I could find nose art for the 375thFS, I'd be interested! ;)  )
      - Simply extract the contents of the file into the mod folder
      Submitter Lacsap Submitted 08/15/2024 Category P-51  
    • By Lacsap
      YOU MUST HAVE THE F-51D/K from FastCargo !
      -Textures in 4K with Normal map and specular map
      - 3 Fighters Squadron WW2 ETO with invasion strips : 487thFS (x11 nose arts), 343rdFS (x5 nose arts), 375thFS (one nose art! if you know of any websites where I could find nose art for the 375thFS, I'd be interested! ;)  )
      - Simply extract the contents of the file into the mod folder
    • By 76.IAP-Blackbird
      Dear Friends, 
      Today we'd like to tell you about the new Great War aircraft that are in development. 
      While transferring them from our classic project Rise of Flight to IL-2 Great Battles, we are fixing problems we found during this work - sometimes there are some asymmetric aerodynamic elements, a wrong object hierarchy, engine overheating/overcooling, and other similar problems. 
       
      For example, while working on the Airco DH.2 recently, we found problems - it had an invisible "ghost" stabilizer in the physical model, inconsistencies in drag values, and it was also missing its top speed - judging by the reference data, it was missing it by about 15 kph. Well, mistakes happen, and they will be corrected: the DH.2 in FC will have recalculated drag values, corrected handling, and an increased top speed. Soon the beta testers will try it out, and some additional changes may be in order after these tests. 
      Its AI will also be updated as it needs to be taught how to use its blip switch for taxiing (such early flying machines had no throttle and the engine always ran at full power - its pilot had to press and hold a blip switch button that cut the ignition when he wanted to slow down). 
       
      Another upcoming aircraft, the Sopwith Pup, also had some problems with its flight characteristics and engine, which are currently being corrected. 
       
       
      While working on Flying Circus aircraft, we are not only adding new features thanks to the IL-2 Great Battles engine but also fixing old problems whenever we get the chance. The new Flying Circus aircraft pack is scheduled for release this summer. 
       
    • By 76.IAP-Blackbird
      Dear friends, 
      Today we'd like to inform you about the upcoming update 5.203. In this update, the AQMG (Advanced Quick Mission Generator) mode will be greatly expanded. New mission types will be added: glider towing to the Normandy and Rhineland maps and artillery spotting and balloon defense to the Western Front WWI map. But the most significant addition will be made to the detailed map of Prokhorovka. 
      Tank Crew will now have a completely new mode that wasn't available before - Ground Forces AQM. Just like its aerial counterpart, it will allow you to choose a specific mission type that will affect the composition and positions of your forces: Strongpoint Defense, Enemy Strongpoint Attack, Breakthrough, and Enemy Rear Area Attack. You'll be able to set an initial distance from the enemy (since ground vehicles are very slow compared to aircraft), the strength of your force, the enemy force, and air support. 
       
       
       
      Other changes in this update include the correction of the distance at which nearby aircraft can be heard, further updates to the Lightning Strikes, Havoc over the Kuban, and Hell Hawks over the Bulge campaigns, various minor improvements such as fixes to career progression, taxiing on certain airfields, mission generation, etc. The popular community-created campaigns Kerch-Eltigen Operation and Battle of the Hürtgenwald will be included in the game with the permission of their authors. 
      We also want to start a multiplayer-related competition today: submit your best in-game tracks of multiplayer action! You can show any action, plane, or tank, as long as it is interesting and recorded in multiplayer (if you already have a saved track that you love and it loads in the game, you can submit it as well). Tracks should be short, showing an interesting event and a few seconds before and after. Please submit your tracks by April 12th. Then we'll choose the best ones - their authors will be awarded Collector planes of their choice and we will create a multiplayer promo video using these tracks. Please post the links to your tracks here or in our Discord channel till the end of April 11th. 
       
    • By 76.IAP-Blackbird
      Dear friends,
      Today we would like to tell you about a new aircraft that our artists have been working on for some time and engineers have recently started to create its FM.
      The Ta 152 is the last creation of the German aircraft designer Kurt Tank, which managed to take part in combat operations during the Second World War. This aircraft was the culmination of the evolution of the Fw 190 fighter and Germany's most advanced piston fighter. It was in development for a long time, several years, and appeared at the very end of the war. During the development, several modifications of the original Fw 190 were produced, which finally led to the Ta 152 - the name "Fw" was changed to "Ta" in recognition of the designer's merits.


      Compared to the Fw 190D "Dora", the wingspan was significantly increased for better maneuverability at high altitudes, the fuselage was longer, and the new Jumo-213E engine was equipped with two boost systems: MW-50 (water-methanol mixture injection for low and medium altitudes) and GM-1 (nitrous oxide for high altitudes). The "Dora" engine was already characterized by a high degree of automation and regulation and thus complexity, but here the Germans went even further - the engine was equipped with a two-stage three-speed (!) supercharger.

      As you can see, these improvements were made for high-altitude combat, where the Ta 152 had to outperform the Mustangs and Spitfires of the Allies - the threat from the bomber armadas climbing higher and higher was growing every year. The plane had a pressurized cockpit and could reach a speed of 750 km/h at an altitude of 12 km, and its ceiling was 14 km! Think about it - a piston fighter that could climb and fight above modern jetliners had no equal. Its armament is also respectable, even by late WWII standards: 30mm MK 108 and two 20mm MG-151/20 cannons allowed it to destroy any air target.


      The Ta 152 went into production at the end of the war and appeared in the skies of Germany in January-February 1945, but due to the disparity of forces, they had no effect on the course of hostilities: they were produced in very small numbers (about 25 H-1s). They remained in history as a monument to German wartime engineering and design. In our simulator, we expect to release this very interesting aircraft this summer.
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..